This module discusses the concept of advance warning, its benefits, and how to implement a range of advance warning devices.
Are Higher Intensity and Greater Reflectivity Better?
A new research study from Emergency Responder Safety Institute (ERSI), "Effects of Emergency Vehicle Lighting Characteristics on Driver Perception and Behavior: Study Report," investigated the impact of lighting color, intensity, modulation, and flash rate on driver behavior while approaching and passing a traffic incident scene at night. The impact of retroreflective chevron markings in combination with emergency lighting configurations, as well as the measurement of "moth-to-flame" effects of emergency lighting on drivers was also investigated. The research was conducted by Dr. John D. Bullogh (formerly with Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and currently with the Light and Health Research Center in the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai) and Dr. Scott Parr of Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University in partnership with ERSI.
The full Study Report is available for download. It's important reading for emergency responders, leaders, standards development organizations, and policy makers. The experiment design and findings are summarized here.
Under different emergency lighting setups volunteer civilians drove a closed course traffic incident scene at night consisting of a simulated fire apparatus in center-block position with a cone taper. Two SAE-compliant, commercially available blue, white, yellow, and red lights were mounted vertically on two tripods spaced apart at a distance approximating the left and right edge of the rear of a fire truck. A silhouette cutout of a firefighter wearing a high visibility safety vest was positioned adjacent to the lights. For some of the tests, researchers placed a panel of retroreflective red/yellow chevrons constructed with ASTM Type V sheeting materials directly behind each flashing light tripod. The researchers tested 14 combinations of lamp color, lamp intensity, pattern, flash rate, and presence of reflective markings next to the lights. Researchers measured vehicle distance to the lights and the distance at which drivers could distinguish the silhouette of a firefighter. They also administered a survey after the driver completed the course. Twenty drivers completed the testing.
The findings will surprise many emergency response professionals.
None of the variables tested had a significant effect on ratings of overall visibility of the road scene. But some individual factors and combined factors yielded findings of interest warranting further research.
Study participants consistently judged higher intensity lights as more glaring but only marginally more visible than lights of lower intensity. Lower intensity lights remained highly visible. Using lower intensities at night will reduce discomfort glare without reducing the lights' visibility. This finding indicates that stationary vehicles in nighttime blocking mode should be sufficiently visible with lower intensity lights.
Drivers' rated visibility of lights appeared to be related to the perceived saturation of their color. Blue and red lights have the greatest perceived saturation and were judged to be brighter than white and yellow lights of the same intensity. Blue and white lights were rated as most glaring. Yellow and red lights were least glaring. This data suggests that red lights for stationary blocking operations may offer the best combination of better visibility with less glare.
"Moth to Flame"
None of the variables tested caused drivers to move their vehicles either toward or away from the lights. Therefore, the data in this test did not support or disprove the "moth to flame" effect.
High Visibility Markings
When fluorescent and reflective markings were present, drivers did not see the firefighter silhouette until they were closer to it. This was the most unexpected finding of the study. Of the four setups tested, high intensity lights with no markings produced the longest detection distance, meaning drivers could see the firefighter silhouette from the furthest away. High intensity lights combined with high visibility markings yielded the shortest detection distance. Reflective markings may increase the amount of scattered light entering the eyes of a driver, thereby making the responder less visible. This study raises the possibility that combining high intensity lights with high visibility markings may make it more difficult for drivers to see responders on foot at night, even when the responders wear high visibility vests. Further research is planned to determine if lower grade retroreflective markings will help improve the conspicuity of emergency personnel operating near emergency vehicles and traffic.
More research is needed to further describe and understand these findings as well as new questions they raise. To stay informed on research into emergency lighting, visit the Emergency Vehicles page on ResponderSafety.com. This page also includes links to additional resources on emergency lighting and emergency vehicles.
This study was produced under a contract between the U.S. Fire Administration and the Cumberland Valley Volunteer Firemen's Association's Emergency Responder Safety Institute, which subcontracted with the Lighting Research Center at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute and Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University to perform the research. Additional funding was provided by the Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University Office of Undergraduate Research and the Dwight D. Eisenhower Transportation Fellowship Program within the U.S. Department of Transportation.News Archive
This module discusses the concept of advance warning, its benefits, and how to implement a range of advance warning devices.
In this program, you will learn the basics of autonomous vehicle technology, the challenges and opportunities it presents to emergency responders, the current state of technology development, and how to begin to prepare for the presence of these vehicles on the roadways you serve.
This module discusses the concept of blocking, why it is important, how to determine whether linear positioning or block positioning is appropriate at a given incident.
In this program, you will learn the basics of connected vehicle technologies, the challenges and opportunities they present to emergency responders, the current state of technology development.
This program raises awareness on how fire department-based vehicles can be outfitted for temporary traffic control at incident scenes, including special purpose vehicles and modifications to vehicles used for fire suppression.
This self-paced program discusses how the fire service and towing personnel can communicate and collaborate effectively to safely and efficiently handle roadway incidents.
The first 15 minutes of a roadway incident response are critical. What the first responding units do, and do not do, will impact the response in many ways, including safety, traffic control, secondary incidents, and clearance time.
This module discusses the importance of helmets and head protection, head protection concerns specific to struck-by incidents, the advantages and disadvantages of available helmet types, and how to evaluate helmet choices for the roadway incident response context.
It is widely known that the visibility of responders is a key factor in safe emergency operation on the roadways.
This program raises awareness about these new devices, technologies, and methods so departments can evaluate whether these options can be adopted in their communities.
This module introduces roadway safety and safe driving practices that fire and life safety educators and all emergency services members who participate in public events can use to reduce the risk of roadway incidents in their communities.
The responsibilities, qualifications standards, qualities, and preparedness needs for fire service traffic incident management professionals.
This program summarizes the federal regulations with regard to high visibility safety apparel, examines the objections of law enforcement officers to wearing this apparel.
In this program, we look at four NIOSH reports on firefighter line-of-duty deaths that occurred while operating at a roadway incident.
This module highlights and explains in plain language the portions of the Manual on Uniform Traffic Control Devices (MUTCD) that apply to first responders working roadway incidents.
This program lays the foundation for successful manual traffic control and offers recommended procedures for manually directing traffic safely and effectively.
The module relates the Move It Work It decision to safe, quick clearance and the National Unified Goal.
This module presents the National Unified Goal as the road map for implementing cross-department cooperation and communication.
This program examines the history of emergency lighting technology, current trends vs. research, problems with current lighting technologies, and potential solutions to address these problems.
This module discusses PPE requirements and how to select, and correctly and consistently wear PPE from head to toe, including high visibility apparel and head protection, to mitigate the hazards of working roadway incidents.
This self-paced program provides guidance for jurisdictions and Traffic Incident Management (TIM) teams to plan for long term events.
This program delves into the topic of professionalism at the organizational and personal level to give both leadership and boots-on-the-ground responders.
This module presents ways to better integrate public safety telecommunicators into the roadway incident response team.
For years, the fire departments have worked to standardize their operating procedures across jurisdictions within geographic areas.
Emergency Medical Services (EMS) vehicles respond to a wide variety of roadway incidents, such as crashes, pedestrians struck by vehicles, other medical emergencies, natural disasters, and weather events.
This self-paced program will assist fire officers with integrating roadway incident safety training into their department, including (but not limited to) self-paced programs and resources available through RSLN and ResponderSafety.com.
This module provides a basic understanding of the framework of traffic control at emergency scenes.
This program prepares safety officers to be advocates in their departments by reviewing recommended traffic incident management and roadway incident safety practices with recommendations for how to implement them.
This self-paced program will provide both an introduction to Safety Service Patrols at the awareness level and recommend vehicle outfitting and roadway operating procedures for SSPs.
This self-paced program discusses the issues created when persons other than responders and victims are present at a roadway incident scene.
This module presents best practices in deploying emergency optical warning devices, called here "emergency lighting."
This self–paced program uses existing Fire Police units as examples for demonstrating how an agency can set up a dedicated traffic incident management unit.
This module presents practical steps law enforcement officers can take to maximize their safety while working sobriety checkpoints.
This module discusses the safety and traffic incident management challenges of vehicle fires and options for responding to these challenges.
This self-paced program discusses the traffic incident management impacts of several special circumstances: HAZMAT, medical helicopters, vehicle extrication, and crash investigation.
This self-paced program provides guidance on how to start and sustain a TIM Team, offering a framework, proven models, and tips for success.
This self-paced program begins with a review of foundational knowledge about the definition of the termination phase and quick clearance strategies. Then, the program covers best practices for typical tasks in the termination phase.
This self-paced program is specifically for first responders who are newer to the profession, typically in their teens and twenties.
This module spotlights how weather impacts emergency scenes on roadways and provides guidance for how to plan and respond when weather conditions significantly affect the incident.
This self-paced program presents information on how to tailor some roadway response best practices to the characteristics of rural roads.
This module highlights the new traffic incident management and responder safety requirements in NFPA 1500: Standard on Fire Department Occupational Safety, Health, and Wellness Program and point departments to resources that will help them meet the requirements of the standard.
This module discusses the use of the Incident Command System (ICS) to manage the response to a roadway incident, both in the context of the Traffic Incident Management (TIM) Team and implementation at the incident scene.
This module presents model policies, practices and procedures for key topics in the traffic incident response and management process, from pre-planning to incident response and through to investigation and post-incident analysis.
This module sets forth a series of vetted best practices for drivers to follow when encountering emergency scenes on the roadway.
This module provides a framework for TIM training and guidance on the techniques and methods used in TIM training.
This self-paced program explores both uses of NFPA 1091, explaining it in "plain language" for emergency responders and discussing how it can be used as a training objectives blueprint.
This self-paced program examines the question, "Who's In Charge at Roadway Incidents?"
This program teaches traffic incident management considerations for roadways affected by wildland fires, firefighting operations, and safety procedures to follow when wildland firefighting vehicles are operating in close proximity to responders on foot.
ResponderSafety.com and The Responder Safety Learning Network (RSLN) are a project of the Emergency Responder Safety Institute (ERSI), a Committee of the Cumberland Valley Volunteer Fireman's Association. The RSLN is an online training network delivering critical safety training for roadway incident responders. All training is free and delivered 24/7/365 on demand. The self-paced modules include critical components of roadway operations safety in an emergency situation, including: Advance Warning, Blocking, High Visibility, Traffic Control, Public Outreach, Incident Command, and more. Register online to get started.